Performance Perspectives Blog

Mutual funds and currency return differences

by | Oct 5, 2010

During last week’s GIPS(R) (Global Investment Performance Standards) conference in San Francisco, I had a conversation with a client who posed an interesting question. They have a US Equity mutual fund that until recently only had U.S. investors. However, a European client made a significant investment in Euros (which were subsequently converted to US Dollars and placed into the fund). To accommodate this investor a separate class was created, where returns will be reported in Euros. In addition, the client requested that a hedge be put on their investment, so a currency forward contract was purchased (to sell US dollars for Euros). The client had two questions: (1) do they place the Euro currency return into the same composite as the portion of the fund that has returns in US dollars (i.e., have accounts with Euro returns mixed with accounts with US returns), and (2) do they include the hedge in the composite?

First, because you might report performance to a client in their (base) currency will have no effect on how you include their account in a composite. How you report top a client is not necessarily the same as how you prepare your GIPS presentations. For example, a client may wish to see a benchmark which is different than you use in the benchmark; this is perfectly fine. Second, all accounts in a composite must have their returns in the same currency:  you can’t mix returns of different currencies in the same composite. You can always convert a return from one currency into another, so this isn’t an issue. In this case, the entire fund is the account. Third, since the hedge was placed at the client’s direction, the firm could, through their documented policies and procedures, consider this a non-discretionary action.

By the way, in yesterday’s Wall Street Journal there was an interesting article on currencies, especially in relation to mutual funds. We’ll discuss this further in a future posting. In the mean time I’m sure you’ll enjoy the article.

Free Subscription!

The Journal of Performance Measurement

The Performance Measurement Resource.

Click to Subscribe